The unreasonable ask
If you love this content (please share it), but also check out my Podcast & connect with me on YouTube / Twitter.
We turn your favorite newsletters into podcasts at 10minmindset.org
The ask changes you more than the answer does.
Vanessa Bohns, a social psychologist at Cornell, has spent fifteen years asking a simple question: when you ask someone for something, how often do they say yes?
She’s tested this across more than 14,000 interactions. Strangers asking strangers for favors, for help, for things that feel like impositions. Before each request, she has the person predict how many people will say yes. Then she sends them out to ask.
The gap between prediction and reality is staggering. People underestimate compliance by 48 percent. Nearly half. And the reason is consistent: when you’re the one asking, you focus on how easy it would be for the other person to decline. You imagine them weighing the cost, finding it too high, and saying no. It feels rational.
But you’re missing the force on the other side. Saying no to someone’s face is uncomfortable. It implies judgment. Most people, when asked for something directly, will find a way to say yes because the social cost of declining feels worse than whatever the request costs them. You know this about yourself. You do it all the time. But you forget it about other people the moment you’re the one asking.
The number you deleted
If people say yes more often than you expect, why do you keep asking for less than you want?
You’ve done this. Drafted the email with the real number, then changed it to something smaller before hitting send. Added a qualifier: “I know this might be a stretch, but...” Watered down the proposal, softened the pitch, asked for ten percent when you wanted twenty. And the reason, if you’re honest about it, had nothing to do with strategy.
The reason is that the ask is a claim. When you put the real number in the email, you’re saying “I think my work is worth this much.” When you pitch the full scope, you’re claiming a level of competence you’ll have to back up. The softened version protects you. If you ask for less and get it, you were being reasonable. If you ask for what you want and hear no, someone just evaluated your claim about yourself and rejected it.
So you pre-reject. You scale down the ask before it leaves your mouth, and the gap between what you wanted and what you asked for becomes a quiet tax on everything you build.
What the asking does to you
Here’s where most advice about bold asks stops: at the outcome. Ask bigger, get more. And that’s true as far as it goes. Bohns’s data confirms it.
But the more interesting thing happens inside the person who asks, regardless of the answer.
The first time you send the email with the real number, your hands sweat. You feel exposed. You’ve made a claim about what you deserve, and now someone else gets to weigh in on it. If they say yes, something shifts. You just learned that asking at that altitude is allowed. You filed that away. The next ask gets a little easier, a little bigger, and the altitude becomes your new baseline.
If they say no, something different happens, and it matters just as much. You survived it. Bohns found that people who got turned down reported the experience was less painful than they’d anticipated. The imagined rejection was worse than the actual one. And now you know that too. The ceiling you were afraid to touch turned out to be a few inches higher than you thought, and next time you’ll reach for it without the same hesitation.
Either way, you became someone who asks at that level. And that identity shift is the real asset, because it compounds in ways that any single yes or no can’t.
The person who asks for the reasonable thing and gets it learns nothing about themselves. The person who asks for the unreasonable thing, whether they get it or not, learns that they’re allowed to want it. And the gap between those two people, after a few years of this, looks from the outside like luck or talent or connections. It’s not. It’s the accumulated effect of asking at a different altitude, hundreds of times, and letting each ask reshape what feels normal.
The altitude gap
Case Kenny has a line: “The universe meets you at your level of audacity.” The universe rewards boldness not because of some mystical law. It rewards boldness because the bold person is often the only person who asked.
Think about any opportunity you’ve watched someone else get. A partnership, a meeting with someone important. Your first instinct is to assume they were chosen. Most of the time, they asked. They sent the cold email and raised their hand in a room where everyone else was waiting to be picked.
And they were able to do this because at some point they made their first unreasonable ask and learned that asking doesn’t break anything. The relationship survives. The other person doesn’t think less of you. The no, when it comes, is polite, and sometimes it comes with a counter-offer that’s better than the safe ask would have produced.
Your sense of what’s “too much” to ask for is miscalibrated by about 48 percent. Every time you honor that miscalibration instead of overriding it, you leave something on the table that someone less talented but more willing to ask is going to pick up.
Send the email with the real number. The answer matters less than what the asking turns you into.
Thank you for reading,
— Scott
My Links