The Best Version of You Shows Up for Strangers
If you love this content (please share it), but also check out my Podcast & connect with me on YouTube / Twitter.
We turn your favorite newsletters into podcasts at 10minmindset.org
Sponsored by MyFitnessPal: I've been using MyFitnessPal for years and it's one of the most useful apps on my phone. You can optimize your sleep, your schedule, your workflow, but if your nutrition is off, none of it performs the way it should. MFP is how I keep that piece dialed in. I log a meal in about 10 seconds, the database has everything in it, and it connects with whatever wearables or health apps you're already using. If you want one tool that quietly makes everything else work better, this is the one I'd start with. Go to podcast.myfitnesspal.com and use code SCOTT for 15% off Premium.
You’re warm, patient, and generous with people who don’t matter. The people who matter most get what’s left over.
Tell me if this sounds familiar.
You’re at a dinner, a work event, a party. You’re sitting next to someone you just met. And for the next hour or two, you’re the best version of yourself. You’re asking questions, following up on things they said ten minutes ago, laughing, making them feel like the most interesting person in the room. You’re all there.
Then you leave. You check your phone. Someone you love sent you a text while you were gone, asking a simple question. You type back one word and don’t think about it again.
Two hours of your best self for someone you’ll probably never see again. One word for someone who’s been in your corner for years.
We all do this. I do it. I catch myself doing it more than I’d like. And the strange part is that it doesn’t feel like a choice while it’s happening. You don’t decide to bring less energy to the people who matter most. You just do, and it’s so natural that nobody questions it until someone close to you gets tired of always getting the version of you that’s already been spent.
The way you show up for a first impression versus the way you show up for a Tuesday night at home. The way you listen when you’re trying to earn someone versus the way you listen when you’ve already got them. Same person. Completely different effort. And the effort goes in exactly the wrong direction.
Why strangers get your best
The answer is simple and it’s worth sitting with for a second. Strangers can leave.
The person at the dinner could have turned to talk to someone else. The new client could have gone with a competitor. That uncertainty, even when it’s small, is what makes you show up. You bring energy because you’re not sure the person will stick around.
The people who love you already stuck around. And somewhere along the way, that safety started working against them. Your brain treats their loyalty like permission to coast. They’re not going anywhere, so the effort gets redirected to wherever the outcome is still up in the air.
I think about this as the safety tax. The people closest to you pay it every day, and the price is that their loyalty earns them less of you, not more. The worst part is that from your side, it doesn’t feel like you’re doing anything wrong. You’re being “comfortable.” You’re being “yourself.” But the gap between comfort and carelessness is a lot smaller than we like to think, and the people on the other side of it can feel the difference even when they can’t name it.
What they see that you don’t
Someone who loves you watches you be warm and funny and present for a room full of people you just met. Then the two of you leave and you go quiet. You’re tired. You’re scrolling. You give half-answers to real questions.
They won’t say “you’re nicer to strangers than you are to me” because it sounds petty even when it’s true. So it comes out in other ways. In a fight about something that seems small but carries the weight of months of feeling like they come last.
From your side, you’re just unwinding. You were “on” for two hours and now you’re home with the person you don’t need to be “on” for. That feels like trust.
From their side, it looks like they’re the one place you’ve decided you don’t need to try.
Why we keep doing it
Alain de Botton wrote something about this that I keep coming back to. He said we can say something sensible and polite to any stranger, but it’s only with the people we love most that we allow ourselves to be unreasonable. His take is almost generous. He frames it as a sign of deep trust. You’re only that unguarded with someone you believe won’t leave.
There’s truth in that. But I think there’s a simpler thing happening too. We stop trying because we can afford to. Strangers carry the risk of walking away. The people who love us carry a near-guarantee of staying. And most of us, without meaning to, send our best energy wherever the risk is highest instead of wherever the love is deepest.
That’s worth noticing. Not because it makes you a bad person. It doesn’t. It makes you a normal person. But noticing it is the first step toward deciding you don’t want normal to be the standard for how you treat the people who chose you.
This shows up at work too
The new hire gets your patience for six weeks. A year later they get one-line messages and an expectation to figure things out on their own.
Your longest client gets slower replies than the new prospect. The prospect gets the thoughtful proposal while the loyal client gets the recycled deck. The people who believed in you first end up getting the least from you, because their commitment made them feel safe, and safe means less effort.
What I’m working on
I don’t have a framework for this. I just have a question I’ve been asking myself when I catch the pattern happening.
If this person could leave as easily as a stranger, would I show up any differently right now?
If the answer is yes, then the only thing standing between them and my best is the fact that they chose to stay. And I don’t want to be someone who gives people less for choosing me. I think most of us don’t want that. We just haven’t noticed how often we’re doing it.
The people who love you deserve at least what the strangers get. Probably a lot more. And the only thing it costs is paying attention at the moments when you’re most tempted not to.
Thank you for reading,
Scott
My Links