Saturday Strategy Sessions
newsletter.scottdclary.com
If you love this content (please share it), but also check out my Podcast & connect with me on YouTube / Twitter.
Today at a Glance
Question: What if meaningful work isn't about finding your passion but about becoming someone worth following?
Quote: "Be so good they can't ignore you, then use that leverage to do work that matters." - Cal Newport
Tool: The "Value Stack Audit" that reveals how to build meaning through excellence rather than chase it through feelings
Question on the Nature of Meaningful Work
What if meaningful work isn't about finding your passion but about becoming someone worth following?
The Passion Prison That Traps High Performers
Most high performers I know are trapped in what I call the "passion prison."
They've bought into the Silicon Valley mythology that meaningful work starts with discovering your calling. Find your passion, follow your heart, do what you love and the money will follow.
It's seductive advice. It promises shortcuts. It suggests that somewhere out there is a perfect job that will make Monday mornings feel like Christmas morning.
But here's what actually happens: You spend years searching for work that feels meaningful while building zero skills that would make any work meaningful. You mistake emotion for direction. You confuse feeling passionate about an idea with being capable of executing it.
The result? Chronic dissatisfaction, constant job hopping, and the nagging sense that everyone else figured out the secret except you.
I've watched brilliant people waste decades this way. MBA graduates who leave consulting to "find themselves" and end up broke and bitter. Engineers who quit stable jobs to pursue art without ever learning how to create art that others value. Executives who abandon successful careers to "follow their passion" for helping people, only to discover they don't know how to help anyone at scale.
The passion-first approach has it backwards.
The Craftsman's Secret: Excellence Creates Meaning
Cal Newport spent five years studying people who genuinely love their work. Not people who post inspirational quotes on LinkedIn, but individuals who wake up excited about their jobs, feel energized by their projects, and can't imagine doing anything else.
His discovery overturns everything we've been taught about meaningful work.
Newport calls this the "craftsman mindset"—an approach that focuses on what you can offer the world rather than what the world can offer you. Like a medieval craftsman who became a master through years of deliberate practice, these modern workers built expertise first, then leveraged that expertise to create work they loved.
The craftsman doesn't ask "What am I passionate about?" They ask "What can I become excellent at that creates value for others?"
These people didn't start with passion. They started with curiosity. They developed skill. They built something valuable. Only then did passion emerge.
Steve Jobs is the poster child for "follow your passion," but his actual story reveals the opposite. In 1972, Jobs was a philosophy student with zero interest in technology. His roommate Steve Wozniak had built a revolutionary computer. Jobs saw a business opportunity—nothing more.
He spent the next decade obsessively developing his craft: product design, market positioning, team building, storytelling. The passion came later, after thousands of hours of deliberate practice building something that mattered.
This isn't just one example. It's the pattern Newport found everywhere.
The violinist who started lessons to please her parents, developed technical mastery through disciplined practice, and only after achieving excellence discovered her "passion" for music.
The surgeon who chose medicine for job security, spent years mastering complex procedures, and only after becoming world-class found meaning in healing.
The entrepreneur who started a business to pay rent, obsessed over creating value for customers, and only after building a successful company realized it was his calling.
Passion follows mastery. Not the other way around.
The Neuroscience of Meaning Creation
Why does the craftsman approach work better than passion-chasing?
Stanford neuroscientists recently mapped what happens in the brain during meaningful work versus passionate work.
When you chase passion without competence, you spike dopamine (anticipation) but generate no serotonin (satisfaction). It's the neurochemical equivalent of being perpetually hungry but never allowed to eat.
When you build competence systematically, you create a different pattern. Dopamine rises steadily during skill development. Serotonin spikes when you create value for others. Norepinephrine increases when you tackle challenges just beyond your ability.
The result? A neurochemical cocktail that naturally generates meaning, purpose, and sustained motivation.
But there's something deeper happening. As you develop expertise, you gain what researchers call "agency"—the ability to shape your environment rather than being shaped by it. Instead of following assignments from others, you start creating your own projects. Instead of consuming value, you begin generating it.
This isn't just career advancement. It's consciousness evolution. You shift from being a cog in someone else's machine to becoming the architect of your own work.
Quote on the Excellence-First Philosophy
"Be so good they can't ignore you, then use that leverage to do work that matters." - Cal Newport
When Newport wrote these words in "So Good They Can't Ignore You," he was directly challenging the entire self-help industry.
Not because he was against meaningful work. But because he'd discovered that the passionate approach creates the opposite of what it promises.
Newport's research followed this pattern across hundreds of cases:
Competence: Years of deliberate practice building rare and valuable skills Recognition: Others begin seeking your expertise and paying premium for it
Leverage: You earn the right to be selective about projects and working conditions Meaning: With leverage comes the ability to shape work around your values
But here's what makes this quote revolutionary: It flips the script on the entire meaning-making process.
Instead of asking "What should the world give me?" it asks "What can I give the world that's so valuable they can't ignore it?"
Instead of optimizing for feeling good, it optimizes for being good at something that matters.
Instead of seeking passion, it builds the competence that creates passion as a byproduct.
Most people reverse this order. They want the leverage and meaning without paying the price of competence and recognition. They want to do work that matters before becoming someone whose work matters.
That's not how excellence works. That's not how meaning works. That's not how careers work.
The craftsman builds first, then chooses. The passionate person chooses first, then hopes someone will pay them for it.
Guess which approach creates more meaningful work?
A Tool You Can Use: The Value Stack
To understand why the craftsman approach works while passion-chasing fails, you need to see how meaningful work actually develops. It's not random—there's a predictable sequence that almost everyone follows, whether they realize it or not.
Most people experience work in three distinct stages:
Stage 1: Job (Survival Mechanism) Work is what you do to survive. Time traded for money. You follow assignments, complete tasks, wait for instructions. Your identity is separate from your work.
Characteristics: Sunday scaries, living for weekends, counting hours, feeling replaceable
Stage 2: Career (Development Path) Work becomes a vehicle for personal growth. You build skills, seek advancement, optimize performance. You start creating your own assignments within larger systems.
Characteristics: Goal-driven, achievement-focused, climbing ladders, building expertise
Stage 3: Calling (Work as Play) Work becomes an expression of who you are. The boundary between work and play dissolves. You can't imagine not doing this work.
Characteristics: Time distortion, effortless focus, creating rather than completing, irreplaceable value
Here's the crucial insight: You can't skip from Stage 1 to Stage 3. There's no shortcut from survival to calling. The only path is through Stage 2—building competence so valuable that you earn the right to do meaningful work.
This is exactly why the passion-first approach fails. It tries to jump straight to Stage 3 without paying the Stage 2 price of developing rare and valuable skills.
The Value Stack: How to Build Meaning Through Excellence
Understanding these stages reveals the real question: How do you systematically progress from Stage 1 to Stage 3? How do you build the competence that creates leverage that enables meaningful work?
The answer is what I call the Value Stack—a framework that focuses on what you can offer the world rather than what the world can offer you.
Instead of asking "What am I passionate about?" ask "What can I become excellent at that creates value for others?"
The Value Stack has four levels:
Level 1: Core Competence Develop a skill so valuable that people will pay you well for it. This isn't about finding your "gift"—it's about choosing something important and becoming systematically excellent at it.
Examples: Writing that changes minds, selling that creates genuine value, building products people love, solving problems that matter
Level 2: Rare and Valuable Combine competencies in ways few others can. The intersection of your skills becomes your unique position.
Examples: Engineering + design, finance + psychology, medicine + technology, writing + business
Level 3: Leverage and Scale Use tools and systems to multiply your impact. Build once, benefit many times.
Examples: Content that teaches thousands, products that serve millions, systems that enable others' success
Level 4: Legacy and Evolution Create work that outlasts you. Enable others to build on what you've built.
Examples: Training successors, open-sourcing knowledge, building institutions that persist
As you climb this stack, meaning emerges naturally. Not because you found your passion, but because you became someone worth following.
The Value Stack Audit
Here's how to assess where you are and design your path forward:
Current Position Assessment:
What skills do you have that others consistently ask for help with?
What problems can you solve that people will pay to have solved?
What combinations of abilities do you possess that are rare?
What leverage do you currently have (audience, platform, resources)?
What legacy are you building (even if unconsciously)?
Development Roadmap:
Choose ONE skill to develop to world-class level over the next 2 years
Identify 3-5 people doing exactly what you want to do
Design a practice routine that pushes the edge of your capabilities daily
Create feedback loops that reveal your progress weekly
Find ways to use your developing skills to help others immediately
The Three Mindset Shifts for the Journey
Building the Value Stack requires abandoning three common misconceptions about meaningful work:
Shift 1: The Paradox of Passionate Work
There's something about meaningful work that catches everyone off guard. It doesn't feel meaningful most of the time.
Even when you love what you do, 80% of it is grinding through resistance, solving boring problems, doing necessary work that isn't inspiring. The meaning comes from the accumulated impact, not the daily experience.
The surgeon saving lives still has to deal with insurance paperwork. The artist creating beauty still has to handle marketing and sales. The entrepreneur changing the world still has to manage cash flow and employee disputes.
This is why passion-chasing fails. It optimizes for feeling good rather than creating good. It seeks inspiration rather than building the competence that makes inspiration relevant.
Shift 2: The Minimum Viable Calling
You don't need to solve world hunger to have meaningful work. You need to solve problems that matter to people who matter to you.
The barista who masters coffee and creates genuine moments of connection for customers has meaningful work. The accountant who develops expertise that helps small businesses thrive has meaningful work. The programmer who builds tools that make other programmers more effective has meaningful work.
Meaning doesn't require scale or recognition. It requires competence applied to problems worth solving.
Shift 3: The Agency Shift
The moment you stop asking "What should I do?" and start asking "What can I build?" everything changes.
But there's something deeper happening here than just a mindset shift. As you develop expertise and climb the Value Stack, you gain what researchers call "agency"—the power to shape your environment instead of being shaped by it.
Most people live in what I call "assignment mode." Your boss assigns your tasks. Your company assigns your schedule. Society assigns your definition of success. You're constantly reacting to other people's agendas.
Agency flips this dynamic. Instead of following assignments, you create your own projects. Instead of consuming value, you generate it. Instead of being a component in someone else's system, you become the architect of your own work.
This isn't about quitting your job. It's about changing your relationship to work itself. Start building something. Solve your own problems and share the solutions. Document your process. Help others navigate what you've navigated.
Your unique combination of experience, perspective, and developing competence is the foundation of meaningful work. Not your passion. Not your calling. Your capability to create value that didn't exist before.
Your Assignment (If You Choose to Accept It)
For the next 30 days, stop asking "What am I passionate about?" and start asking "What problem can I solve?"
Pick one skill that matters. Practice it deliberately every day. Document what you learn. Share it with others.
Watch meaning emerge not from feeling but from building. Not from finding yourself but from creating value.
The world doesn't need more people following their passion. It needs more people becoming excellent at work that matters.
The passion will come. But first, become someone worth following.
Start building.
Thank you for reading,
Scott
What lands here isn’t the Newport quote, it’s the quiet insult hidden in it: if you haven’t earned leverage, your “passion” is just a mood. The older I get, the more I trust what the hands know. In a kitchen, you can feel the difference between romance and craft by how a blade moves through an onion. In an OR, you learn fast that meaning isn’t a feeling - it’s consequence. Competence is the only language reality speaks.
Your “Value Stack” reads like body wisdom: friction → skill → agency → meaning. Most people try to jump straight to meaning and wonder why they’re anxious. They’re chasing a neurochemical high without the scar tissue that makes it stick. The work that matters is usually 80% unsexy: repetition, revisions, boring problems solved cleanly. The 20% that feels like purpose only shows up because the 80% was done without applause.
Where I’d push this further: excellence isn’t just a career strategy, it’s a moral stance. “Be so good they can’t ignore you” becomes “be so reliable reality can trust you.” That’s heavier than passion; it survives bad days, low dopamine, and silence.
One question for your readers: if you stripped the slogans and removed the audience, what skill would you still practice in an empty room for the next two years, because the craft itself makes you more useful, more dangerous, more alive?
Start there. The meaning will find you.
This reframing of meaningful work is powerful; and honestly, a bit of a wake-up call. The idea that passion follows mastery, not the other way around, challenges so much of what we’re taught about career fulfillment.
I appreciate how you broke down the neuroscience behind it too. It’s not just philosophy, it’s biology. The “craftsman mindset” feels like a more grounded, sustainable path, especially in a world obsessed with instant gratification.
Thank you for articulating this with such clarity and depth.