The most useful advice you hear this year might come from someone you can’t stand.
Hi All!
Here is my weekly letter discussing mental models, performance, business and entrepreneurship.
If you love this content (please share it), but also…
Check out my Podcast, connect with me on YouTube / Twitter, and read my Weekly newsletter.
How To Learn From Someone You Don’t Like
You probably know the feeling. Someone you can’t stand starts talking in a meeting, and before they’ve finished the sentence you’ve already decided they’re wrong. Maybe they took credit for your work last quarter, or they talk to the junior people like they’re furniture, or they’re smug in a way that gets under your skin. Then the idea they pitched is the one the team goes with, and three months later it’s working.
A few weeks ago I posted a graphic that said you can disagree with someone and still learn from them, and you can dislike someone and still respect their perspective. It ended with “Everything is either amazing or terrible. Try the middle.” A lot of people shared it, and I understand why, because almost everyone agrees with that in principle. Doing it with one specific person, the coworker or competitor or relative who drives you up the wall, is a lot harder, especially when listening to them feels like letting them off the hook.
Some of that difficulty is built in. Psychologists call it reactive devaluation, the tendency to rate an idea as worse once you know it came from someone on the other side. In a study published in 2002, researchers showed Israeli participants a real peace proposal that had been drafted by Israeli negotiators. When it was labeled as a Palestinian proposal, Israeli Jewish participants rated it less favorably than when the identical text was labeled as Israeli, so the only thing that changed their verdict was who they thought wrote it.
That’s an extreme setting, but you do a smaller version of it every week. And it costs you more than the occasional good idea, because if you only take lessons from people you like, you mostly learn from people who already see things the way you do.
This Thursday edition is for paid subscribers. If you’re reading this and you’re not subscribed, you can fix that here.


