Growth Lives in the Parts You'd Rather Delete
If you love this content (please share it), but also check out my Podcast & connect with me on YouTube / Twitter.
We turn your favorite newsletters into podcasts at 10minmindset.org
You learned more from the things you got wrong than from anything you got right. That's why you can't stop thinking about them at 3am.
Sponsored by LinkedIn Ads: I get dozens of ads served to me every week. Most of them have nothing to do with me. Wrong industry, wrong stage, wrong everything. They’re burning budget on people who were never going to convert. That’s the problem with most ad platforms. You’re paying for eyeballs, not the right eyeballs.
LinkedIn Ads flips that. You can target by job title, company size, industry, seniority, skills, even specific companies on your prospect list. You’re not guessing who sees your ad. You’re choosing. And it works. LinkedIn Ads has the highest ROAS of any major ad network at 121%. That’s not a vanity metric. That’s real dollars back on every dollar spent.
If you’re running a startup and want to test it, LinkedIn is offering a $250 ad credit to get started. Learn more at LinkedIn.com/ScottClary.
Everyone has a 3am file.
You know what I’m talking about. The mental folder that opens when you can’t sleep. The moments you replay on loop, wishing you could go back and choose differently. The thing you said that you can’t unsay. The person you hurt when you were too selfish to notice you were hurting them. The opportunity you destroyed through arrogance. The relationship you ruined before you understood what you had.
You don’t choose when the file opens. It just does. You’re lying there, half asleep, and suddenly you’re back in that moment. Reliving it in high definition. Feeling the same shame you felt then, except now it’s worse because you’ve had years to understand exactly how wrong you were.
Nobody talks about this file. Not publicly. Not on social media. Not at dinner parties. Because the file contains the versions of yourself that don’t match who you pretend to be. The versions you’d delete from your history if you could.
You can’t delete them. And you shouldn’t. Because those versions taught you more than every win, every achievement, and every proud moment combined.
The Lesson That Only Comes From Living It
Some lessons you can only learn by living through them. Not by reading. Not by advice. Not by watching someone else go through it. By being the person who did the wrong thing and lived with what came next.
I’ve interviewed over 800 people on the show. Founders, CEOs, operators, athletes, artists. When I ask about their biggest lessons, almost nobody points to a win. They point to a failure. A mistake. A moment they’re not proud of.
The founder who lost his entire first company because he couldn’t listen to feedback. He learned to listen. Not from a management book. From the experience of watching something he built collapse because he refused to hear what people were telling him.
The executive who got fired for being impossible to work with. She rebuilt her career from scratch and became the kind of leader people fight to work for. Not because she studied leadership. Because she lived the consequences of bad leadership and decided never to be that person again.
The entrepreneur who burned through every important relationship in his twenties, treating people as stepping stones, and spent his thirties rebuilding them one at a time. He’s one of the most generous connectors I know now. That generosity wasn’t born from abundance. It was born from the shame of what he was like when he had nothing to give.
Every one of these people would erase those moments if they could. And every one of them would lose the exact qualities that make them exceptional now.
That’s the paradox nobody wants to sit with. The worst version of you built the best version of you. You can’t keep one and delete the other. They’re connected. One led to the other.
Why Shame Teaches More Than Pride
Think about your proudest moments. The wins. The achievements. The times everything went right.
What did they actually teach you? Probably not much. They confirmed what you already believed. You were talented. You made good choices. The approach worked. The win validated the path. It felt great. But you went into that moment as one person and came out as the same person, just with more confidence.
Now think about your most shameful moments. The things you cringe about. The times you were the villain in someone else’s story.
Those taught you everything.
Because shame is a specific signal. It’s not generic guilt. It’s not vague discomfort. Shame fires when something you did violated your own values. Not someone else’s standards. Yours. The things you believe about who you should be. The code you hold yourself to.
You don’t feel shame about things you don’t care about. You feel shame about things that matter deeply to you. Standards you hold yourself to. That you failed to meet.
That’s why the 3am file keeps opening. Your brain isn’t torturing you. It’s showing you the gap between who you were in that moment and who you want to be. And that gap is where all the growth lives.
Pride closes the gap. It says “you’re already who you want to be.” Feels good. Teaches nothing.
Shame opens the gap. It says “you’re not there yet.” Feels terrible. Teaches everything.
Psychologist June Tangney spent decades studying this. Her research found that shame, when processed rather than avoided, is one of the strongest predictors of behavioral change. People who sit with their shame, who don’t run from it or rationalize it away, are significantly more likely to change the behavior that caused it. The discomfort isn’t the problem. It’s the mechanism.
The 3am file isn’t a punishment. It’s your brain running the program that changes you. And it only runs on moments painful enough to matter.
The Highlight Reel Is Built on the Lowlights
We instinctively want to erase our worst moments. Curate a version of our past that only includes the wins. Social media made this worse. You can literally construct a public version of your life with no failures, no shame, no cringe moments. And the more time you spend maintaining that version, the more you start believing it.
But the moments you’re erasing are load-bearing. Remove them and the person you are today doesn’t make sense.
Your patience exists because impatience once cost you something you cared about. The empathy you have now was built in a moment where you had none and watched someone you loved absorb the impact.
You can’t keep the growth and erase the teacher. They’re not separate. The growth IS the scar tissue from the wound.
People point to their best moments and say “that’s who I am.” The promotion. The successful launch. The relationship that works. But those are outputs. The inputs were the shameful moments. The failures that taught you what works. The relationships you ruined before you learned how to maintain one. The career mistakes that showed you what actually matters.
Your highlight reel is the result of your lowlights. The polished version exists because the unpolished version went through something painful enough to cause a permanent change.
We want to believe we were always this person. The good version. But we weren’t. We were the other version first. And that version did the hardest work of our lives. Not in a gym. Not in a boardroom. In the quiet aftermath of a mistake, where you sit with what you did and decide whether you’re going to stay that person or become someone different.
That decision, made in the wreckage of your own behavior, is the one that actually changes people. Because it’s not theoretical. It’s not “I should be better.” It’s “I was the worst version of myself and I never want to be that person again.” The first is an idea. The second changes your behavior.
The Versions You Carry
You’re carrying every version of yourself right now. The current one. The one you’re proud of. But also the ones you’d rather forget. The one who drank too much and said something awful. The one who failed publicly. The one who chose ego over empathy and watched someone’s face change.
Those versions aren’t deleted software from an old operating system. They’re still running. Still active. Still informing every decision you make. When you pause before speaking, that’s an old version reminding you what happens when you don’t. When you choose kindness you didn’t used to have, that’s an old version whispering “remember what happened when you didn’t.”
You’re not the person you are today despite your worst moments. You’re the person you are today because of them.
The most empathetic people I’ve met aren’t the ones who were naturally kind. They’re the ones who were unkind once, in a way that mattered, and decided to change. The most thoughtful communicators aren’t the ones who always knew the right thing to say. They’re the ones who said the wrong thing once and still remember the silence that followed.
The best versions of people are almost always built on the ruins of their worst versions. Not because suffering is noble. Because suffering shows you exactly who you don’t want to be. Comfort never does that. It shows you exactly who you don’t want to be. And knowing who you don’t want to be turns out to be more useful than any amount of inspiration about who you do want to be.
The 3am Audit
Most people let the 3am file torture them passively. The moment replays. The shame washes over. You cringe, toss, eventually fall back asleep. Nothing changes. Same file. Same loop. Same shame without purpose.
There’s a way to use it instead of just enduring it.
Take one item from your 3am file. The one that comes up most often. The moment you’ve replayed the most times. And instead of just cringing through it, write four things down.
What did I do? Be specific. Not “I was a bad friend.” The actual thing. What you said. What you chose. What you didn’t do that you should have.
What did it cost? Who was affected? What did you lose? What changed in the relationship, the opportunity, the situation because of what you did?
What did it teach me? What do you understand now that you didn’t understand then? What value of yours did you violate? What did the shame reveal about what actually matters to you?
What do I do differently now because of it? This is the important one. Where’s the direct line between that moment and how you behave today? What decision do you make now that you wouldn’t have made before that moment happened?
When you see those four things written down, something shifts. The shame transforms. It stops being this formless, 3am dread and becomes something traceable. A clear line from the worst version to the current version. Evidence that the moment wasn’t wasted. That the pain produced something. That you actually changed because of it.
Most people never do this. They carry the shame without ever processing it into something useful. The moment stays in the file as raw pain instead of becoming what it actually is: proof that you grew.
Do this for one item from your file this week. Just one. Write the four things down. See the line from who you were to who you are.
Then do it for the next one. And the next.
You’ll start to see a pattern. The person you are today isn’t a random collection of good qualities. It’s a very specific set of responses to a very specific set of failures. Every strength traces back to a weakness that cost you something. Every good habit traces back to a bad one that finally became too expensive to keep.
Your 3am file isn’t random pain. It’s a blueprint. You just never laid it out clearly enough to see it.
The 3am Reframe
The next time the file opens and you’re lying there replaying some moment from years ago, wishing you could go back and be different, consider this:
You already went back.
You’ve been going back every day since it happened. Every time you choose differently because of that moment, you’re going back. Every time you show up better than that version could have, you’re going back.
You can’t change what happened. But you already changed what happens next. You’ve been changing it for years. Quietly. Without credit. Without anyone knowing that the kindness you show now was built by a moment of cruelty you’ll never forget.
That’s what growth looks like from the inside. Not a highlight reel. Not a transformation montage. Just a person carrying their worst moments forward and using them as instructions for how to be better.
Your 3am file isn’t a list of failures. It’s a list of teachers. Brutal ones. The kind you didn’t choose and wouldn’t wish on anyone.
The worst version of you built the best version of you. That doesn’t make the worst version okay. It makes the best version real.
And real is the only kind of growth that lasts.
Thank you for reading,
Scott
My Links